Guides for loan officers

Should You Refinance? The Questions Worth Asking First

Every time rates move, past clients start asking whether they should refinance. It is a fair question, and it does not have a one-size answer. Refinancing replaces the current loan with a new one, and whether that helps depends on the rate, the costs, and how long the borrower plans to stay.

What refinancing actually does

A refinance pays off the existing mortgage and starts a new one, usually with different terms. The new loan may have a lower rate, a different term length, or a different loan type. It may also let a borrower take cash out, though that is a separate decision with its own tradeoffs.

The key point is that refinancing is a new loan, not a modification of the old one. That means a new application, new paperwork, and new closing costs, even when the borrower stays with the same lender.

The math that matters

The simple version of the math is the monthly savings against the cost of refinancing. If a refinance may save a certain amount per month, and the closing costs are a known amount, dividing the costs by the monthly savings gives a rough break-even point in months. A borrower who plans to stay well past that point may come out ahead, while a borrower who may move soon may not recover the costs.

That math is only rough, though. It changes if the new loan has a longer term, which can lower the payment while increasing total interest over time. Comparing total cost, not just the monthly payment, gives a fuller picture.

When it may make sense

Refinancing may be worth a look when rates have fallen meaningfully below the current rate, when the borrower wants to remove mortgage insurance after building equity, or when switching loan types fits a changed situation. A borrower whose credit has improved since the original loan may also qualify for better terms now.

It may also help to shorten the term, for example moving from thirty years to fifteen, though that usually raises the payment even as it reduces total interest. That tradeoff suits some households and not others.

When staying put may be better

Refinancing may not help when the savings are small, when the borrower may move or pay off the loan soon, or when the costs eat up years of savings. It also may not help when the current loan has a rate that is already competitive, or when the borrower would reset the clock on a loan they have nearly paid down.

The right move is to run the numbers for the specific loan, not to follow a general rule about rates. A loan officer can lay out the break-even point and the total cost side by side, so the decision is based on the borrower's own figures.

LO Market Update sends your database one plain explanation like this every month under your name, so your clients ask the right questions before they chase a rate headline.

Want this done for you?

A newsletter like this, written for you every month — white-labeled under your name, ready to send. $4.99/month or $49/year.

Get started

← All guides